Circumvention Analysis on a Taiwan Patent Infringement Case – Glass Gripper of Patents on Door Frame Structure

Traditionally in the arena of TRIZ, patent circumvention that is based on the legal document of a patent is achieved by using trimming to delete one of the elements in the independent claim, or significantly modifying the function, way, result of certain element. However, its results are seldom verified by patent infringement test procedure. This paper uses a real infringement case in Taiwan Intellectual Property Court, case 102 of civil procedure in the year of 2014, where the defendant’s product, non-glue glass gripper, is compared with the plaintiff’s patent claim of TW584161, the improvement of frame structure. And there is no significant difference between the product and the patent claim in terms of function, way and result, thus resulting in infringement. Afterwards, TRIZ tools such as function analysis and trimming are used to pin down two crucial questions, followed by brain storming to develop circumvention solutions 1 and 2. Then follow the patent infringement test procedure such as read on, all elements rule, doctrine of equivalents, to ensure these two circumvention solutions indeed do not infringe the patent claim of patent TW584161. Function analysis shows that the elements of the first claim of patent TW584161 includes: frame body, packing element, gripping element, adjusting element and glass sheet. The feature of this patent is to rotate the adjusting element to move up the packing element to further have the two grippers of gripping element come closer to grip the glass sheet firmly. The feature of the circumvention solution 1 is that the resisting element is solid and with protruding part which can be inserted into the undercut glass sheet unto the securing of the glass sheet. The feature of the circumvention solution 2 is to move the plastic sealing module by hand to activate its locking position for the purpose of positioning the glass sheet.
- Altschuller, G. (1984). Creativity as an Exact Science: the Theory of the Solution of Inventive Problems. New York: Gordon and Breach.
- Bukhman, I. (2012). TRIZ Technology for Innovation. Taipei: Cubic Creativity Company.
- Chen, J, T. (2009). Innovative design-around patent: using innovative design-around patent to create invention for patent application. Taipei: Intellectual Property Office. (In Chinese)
- Durham, A. (1999). Patent Law Essential: A Concise Guide. Westport, CT: Quorum Books.
- Gadd, K. (2002), TRIZ for Engineers – Enabling Inventive Problem Solving. West Sussex, UK: Wiley.
- Green Marketing Association (2015). Thermal insulation principle of heat insulation material: thermal insulation knowledge from Bridge-Cut Aluminum Alloy door and windows. Retrieved July 11th, 2016 from: https://www.my6688.tw/index.php?module=faq&mn=1&f=content&tid=11040 (In Chinese)
- Huang, H. Y. (2014). The Technology of Patent Infringement Avoidance on Food: The Utility of a Combination of Stuffing and Dough with Lactic Acid Bacteria M427791. The Journal of INNOvation Research & Development, 10(1), 51-63. (In Chinese)
- Intellectual Property Court Verdict (Year 2014, No. 102 – Civil Law). Retrieved July 11th, 2016 from http://jirs.judicial.gov.tw/FJUD/ (In Chinese)
- Li, M., Ming, X., He, L., Zheng, M. and Xu, Z. (2015). A TRIZ-based Trimming method for Patent design around. Computer-Aided Design, 62, 20–30.
- Liu, C. T. (1991). Structure Improvements for Aluminum Extrusion Door Frame. Taiwan Utility Patent No. 167102. (In Chinese)
- Liu, S. J., Chang, T. P., & Chen, H. Y. (2013). Using US Patent Cases to Analyze the Doctrine of Equivalents in Patent Law Ruled by the Supreme Court of R.O.C. Taiwan Law Journal, 219, 112-143. (In Chinese)
- Liu, T. L., Guo, C. Z., & Zhuang, Z. H. (2012). A Study of Applying TRIZ to Patent Analysis Strategies. 2012 Annual Conference of Taiwan TRIZ Association, 223-232. National Taipei University of Technology, Taiwan. (In Chinese)
- Lu, K. H. & Shih, T. Y. (2014). A Study of the Process of New Product Design-Integrating the Patent Design Around, QFD and TRIZ. Management Information Computing, 3, 241-251. (In Chinese)
- Lu, M.T. (2014). Insight of Patent (the 4th edition). Taipei: Chuan Hwa Book Co., Ltd. (In Chinese)
- Mann, D. (2002). Hands-on systematic innovation. leper Belgium: Creax press.
- Mueller, J. M. (2012). Patent Law, 4th ed.. Aspen Publishers.
- Sheu, C. H. (2003). Structure Improvements of door frame. Taiwan Utility Patent No. 584161. (In Chinese)
- Sheu, D. D. & Hou, C. T. (2013). TRIZ-based trimming for process-machine improvements: Slit-valve innovative redesign. Computers & Industrial Engineering, 66(3), 555–566.
- Sun, Y. & Ikovenko S. (2015). TRIZ: a Golden Key to the Door of Innovation: Part I (pp.17-43). China Science Publishing & Media Ltd. (In Chinese)
- Yen, C. C. (a) (February, 3rd, 2010). The analysis of patent infringement litigation cases in Taiwan: Part 1. North America Intellectual Property Newsletter, 32. Retrieved July 11th, 2010 from http://www.naipo.com/portals/1/web_tw/Knowledge_Center/Infringement_Case/publish-18.htm (In Chinese)
- Yen, C. C. (b) (March, 31st, 2010). The analysis of patent infringement litigation cases in Taiwan: Part 2. North America Intellectual Property Newsletter, 33. Retrieved July 11th, 2010 from http://www.naipo.com/portals/1/web_tw/Knowledge_Center/Infringement_Case/publish-20.htm (In Chinese)
- Yen, C. C. (c) (July, 1st, 2010). The analysis of patent infringement litigation cases in Taiwan: Part 5. North America Intellectual Property Newsletter, 36. Retrieved July 11th, 2010 from http://www.naipo.com/portals/1/web_tw/Knowledge_Center/Infringement_Case/publish-25.htm (In Chinese)
- Yen, C. C. (c) (May, 3rd, 2010). The analysis of patent infringement litigation cases in Taiwan: Part 3. North America Intellectual Property Newsletter, 34. Retrieved July 11th, 2010 from http://www.naipo.com/portals/1/web_tw/Knowledge_Center/Infringement_Case/publish-21.htm (In Chinese)
- Yen, C. C. (d) (June, 3rd, 2010). The analysis of patent infringement litigation cases in Taiwan: Part 4. North America Intellectual Property Newsletter, 35. Retrieved July 11th, 2010 from http://www.naipo.com/portals/1/web_tw/Knowledge_Center/Infringement_Case/publish-23.htm (In Chinese)
- Zhao, M., Shi, X., & Duan, H. (2009). TRIZ Introduction and Practice. China Science Publishing & Media Ltd. (In Chinese)
- Zhao, M., Zhang, W. C., & Wang, F. S. (2015). TRIZ Enhancement and Practical Applications. China Machine Press. (In Chinese)